You Are Blind to Your BiasWednesday 18 February 2015
You’ve had diversity training, you’re open-minded and up to date, so you treat everyone the same, right? As a matter of fact, it’s pretty much a certainty that whatever your management style, you are regularly treating somebody, somewhere different from someone else. Because of their race, gender, sexuality – any number of things that make them different from, or similar to, you. And you aren’t even aware that you are doing it.
It’s all because of your brain, which makes split-second, instinctive decisions about the world you live in and how you should behave. Our brains have two strategies – or systems – for making decisions and assessing the environment, explains Dan Robertson, diversity and inclusion director of Employers Network for Equality & Inclusion. Both of them help to inform management styles.
System one does its thinking fast, and works at an unconscious level. It’s useful because it quickly processes the enormous amount of information we encounter every day. But in making rapid judgements it also takes shortcuts – based on our experiences, culture, emotions and instincts – that can lead to stereotyping and inadvertent, hidden, bias. System two is all about concentration, attention and effort (the kind of thinking we use to fill out a tax return), and our mind doesn’t really like to do it, which is why it is so easy (and common) to default to system one.
Due to system one, we form what Robertson calls “preferred people preferences” that affect our unconscious social preferences.
We may demonstrate this type of bias, he says, in “micro-behaviours”. For example, we may exhibit an affinity bias, where we respond positively to people who are similar to us or with whom we have something in common. We might give that person more airtime in a meeting, or agree more often with what they say. In contrast, we might cut short those with whom we do not have an affinity, or disregard their viewpoints. These are subtle behaviours, and very different from what we think of as discriminatory behaviour, which is overt and conscious.
The bad news is that we can’t eliminate these biases altogether. They are hard-wired into us. The good news is that our knowledge of them is based on science and evidence, which can make them a firm avenue by which to engage with inclusion in the workplace. Best of all, by being aware of them, and looking for trends and patterns, we can change the way we work to limit the behind-the-scenes damage they can do.
How To Beat Your Bias
Get rid of groupthink. While there’s a value to a cohesive culture and tight-knit team, there’s also a danger that where people share similar backgrounds and values they can fall victim to “groupthink” and make decisions that aren’t questioned. Be aware of the potential for the members of a group with similar backgrounds to reinforce each other’s thinking and potentially narrow the organisation’s outlook.
Go deeper with diversity. “There are many organisations with workforces that have a mix of ethnicity, sexuality, disability, but often those groups are at the lower end of the organisation,” says Dan Robertson, diversity and inclusion director of Employers Network for Equality & Inclusion. Bias testing can help create true inclusivity, for instance by identifying patterns of exclusion throughout the employment cycle.
Strike back at stress. When you are under pressure fast thinking is more likely to operate – and you are more likely to rely on your instincts. Creating an organisation where people have the opportunity to talk about decisions and time to consider actions could lead to less biased decisions.
Hide the hints. The recruitment process is a place where unconscious bias manifests itself. Actions that take it out of the equation can make a difference. For instance, removing candidates’ biographical information – such as their hobbies and education – and focusing instead on competency-based information is once way to remove opportunities for bias.
What I’ve Learned
Lucy Thornley - assistant chief executive (people and development), Greater Manchester Probation Trust, learned that bias has no place in management through teamwork training on a CMI course
Our working environment is changing. And CMI training is helping us to keep ahead. We were the first probation trust to achieve the Investors in People Gold Award and we have an ambitious change programme. Our staff work with the most disadvantaged groups in society and need to exercise professional judgement in their work with offenders. Our managers need to support them.
There’s strength in teamwork. I joined 20 colleagues on the course and it was great to work closely with people I don’t see often. As a senior manager it’s good to get out of headquarters, share good practice and see if the messages we think are getting out are actually reaching everyone.
Freedom can be daunting. Increased flexibility for staff will encourage innovation and creativity, but some people may feel anxious about changes. Our programme is underpinning the changing culture, helping support staff and resulting in better performance for the service.
I take on more than I need to. I’ve not been good at delegating and by talking to my team I found they were keen to take on more responsibility. Sharing tasks with them has been invigorating for me and it has given them greater responsibility.
People don’t understand what probation does. And when I first saw my job advertised, I realized I didn’t know much about probation either. As a service, we need to improve our profile and public understanding of the work we do. Crucially, it’s about public protection and working with people to stop their offending behaviour, but it’s also about supporting them to turn their lives around.
People can change. And believing that is fundamental to everything that we do. Our staff go the extra mile and are dedicated to the services we provide.
Lucy completed the CMI Level 5 Certificate in Management Coaching and Mentoring with the help of Adalta Development. Find out more at www.adaltadevelopment.co.uk
Our extensive range of articles are designed to keep you in the loop with all the latest management and leadership best practice, research and news.
Members See More
CMI Members have access to thousands of online learning and CPD resources. Learn more about our membership benefits
Join The Community
CMI offers a variety of flexible membership solutions, tailored to your needs. Find out more and get involved in the CMI community today.