From apprenticeships and qualifications to professional development and employability skills. Supporting learners, partners, and centres with tools to deliver, assess, and grow.
Join a professional community committed to excellence in management and leadership. Access exclusive resources, and recognition pathways including Chartered Manager.
Connect, celebrate, and lead with CMI’s vibrant community. From events and awards to networks and campaigns, get involved and help shape the future of management.
Stay informed with expert insights, thought leadership, and the latest in management. From in-depth features to practical guidance, explore the ideas shaping today’s workplace.
Learn about CMI’s mission, values, and impact. From our Royal Charter to governance, careers, and sustainability commitments, discover who we are and what drives us.
06 January 2015 -
Jermaine Haughton
One of the UK’s most famous inventors, Sir James Dyson, has joined a backlash against home secretary Theresa May’s plans to force foreign students out of the country once they have finished their studies. Announced during the Christmas period, the policy has been tipped for inclusion in the Tory election manifesto – as per May’s wishes – as she makes a push for zero net student migration.
From a political standpoint, the proposals have been viewed as an attempt to win round potential UKIP voters. However, Dyson – who recently unveiled plans to dramatically boost R&D at his household-gadgets firm – said in a Guardian column that vote-chasing pledges would only have a negative effect on UK manufacturing and production skills in the long term.
“Theresa May’s latest ploy to swing voters concerned about immigration magnifies my worry: she wants to exile foreign students upon qualification from British universities,” he wrote. “Train ’em up. Kick ’em out. It’s a bit short-sighted, isn’t it? A short-term vote winner that leads to long-term economic decline. Of course the government needs to be seen to be ‘doing something’. But postgraduate research in particular leads to exportable, patentable technology. Binning foreign postgraduates is, I suppose, a quick fix. But quick fixes don’t build long-term futures. And that’s exactly what many researchers are doing.”
According to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), 51,000 of the 121,000 non-EU students that came to the UK in the year up to June 2014 have now departed, presenting a net gain of 70,000. However, Dyson urged: “Our borders must remain open to the world’s best. Give them our knowledge, allow them to develop their own and permit them to apply it on our shores. Their ideas and inventiveness will create technology to export around the world.”
He added: “May’s immigration plans simply force the nimble minds we nurture to return home and create competition overseas. Why would they return? Often they hail from emerging economies and nations that respect science and engineering. The hard truth is that the homegrown postgraduate population is pitifully thin, so companies such as Rolls-Royce take their research and engineering capability overseas.”
The ONS has predicted that numbers of foreign students will continue to rise in the UK by 6% per year up to 2020. However, experts have suggested that a potential steady stream of young workers could help to offset the country’s ageing population. According to Moody’s, 18% of UK citizens will be in the over-65 bracket by 2015 – a figure that will rise to almost 22% by 2030.
Dyson argued that technology and manufacturing firms are already struggling to find talent and legislative support on their own shores – and their predicament could get even worse in the light of a foreign-graduate freeze-out, with the economy needing at least another 640,000 engineers by 2020 to have a hope of sustainable growth.
“Dyson is searching for scientists and engineers,” he wrote. “But there simply are not enough … Recently, American-born, British-based neuroscientist John O’Keefe suggested the government’s visa restrictions limited applications of bright foreign students to British universities. O’Keefe’s research into the brain’s GPS system at University College London won a Nobel prize. To take his research further, he needs to expand his team. But guess what? He’s struggling.”
He added: “We look for polymaths excited by problem solving and unafraid to test limits. Skills British universities teach like no other. One mistake has been seeing our world-class education as an export. Britain offers foreign students the best education in return for eye-watering fees. We think that’s a good little ‘industry’.
“Yes, these students net Britain nearly £7bn each year. But sending them home with new technology developed here presents very good value to our competitor nations. Instead, our education system should be a tool to import the world’s greatest minds. And, most importantly, to keep them here, so our economy – and our culture – benefits.”
For more thoughts on harnessing skills, sign up to this forthcoming CMI seminar Managing the Value of Your Talent.
Image of Sir James Dyson courtesy of the Wikimedia Commons.
› The persistence of presenteeism and other nuanced nonsense
› A new age of vulnerability: why inclusive leadership matters more than ever
› Ask yourself: "How do I make my employees feel?"
› Finance and the Diversity Dividend
For more information or to request interviews, contact CMI's Press Team on 020 7421 2705 or email press.office@managers.org.uk
› The 5 Greatest Examples of Change Management in Business History
› Four companies that failed spectacularly, and the lessons of their premature demise
› 6 companies that get employee engagement – and what they do right
› 4 Signs That Racism May Be An Issue In Your Workplace
› How to build an Effective Team: focus on just 3 things